Silence Sexual and Reproductive Health Discussions and We Fuel the Rise of HIV/AIDS in Sub-Saharan Africa
By Janet M. Wojcicki, PhD, MPH
I worked as an anthropologist interviewing commercial and informal sex-workers in Johannesburg and Soweto, South Africa in the mid to late 1990s. During this time, as South Africa was emerging from decades of apartheid legislation, and into the brutal reality of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, stigma surrounding diagnosis and testing were fueling the spread of HIV. These were brutal times - the epidemic of HIV/AIDS exploded from less than 1% of the population infected in 1990 to more than 20% in 2000. The commercial and informal sex workers who I interviewed were often not seeking HIV testing, counseling or treatment because of their fears of derogatory comments and judgments from health workers.
Since the mid-1990s, South Africa, as the country with the largest number of individuals living with HIV and AIDS (6.1 in 2012 and 7 million in 2015), has made significant strides in the fight against HIV/AIDS. Indeed, some of this can be explained by the emergence of access to antiretroviral therapies (ARTs) but perhaps, more importantly, there has been a widespread effort to de-stigmatize sexual behaviors and marginalized population groups and increase the uptake of voluntary testing and counseling although this work is by no means complete. The National Institute of Health (NIH), US federal and other governmental and private foundation have helped in this process by funding interventions to reduce stigma and organizations that counsel on reproductive and sexual health as a means to encourage testing and treatment of HIV/AIDS.
Meanwhile, however, these problems persist and continue and HIV-related stigma and isolation impact those infected as well as prevents access to services for those who may not know infection status. The WHO cites stigma and fear as the main reasons that individuals are reluctant to get tested, disclose their status and take ARTs. Specifically, one of the most significant barriers to ART adherence is on-going negative experience and perceived stigma from healthcare providers. Reluctance to get tested and initiate treatment results in increased risky behaviors and spread of disease to others.
South Africa and reproductive health counseling
Unlike other sub-Saharan African countries, South Africa is relatively unique in the region and in sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere in being one of a few that provides legal termination of pregnancy via the Choice of Termination of Pregnancy Act, Act 92 of 1996 (the others include Mozambique, Cape Verde and Zambia). One out of every three women aged 15–24 experiences unintended pregnancy before the age of 20 in South Africa. In Southern Africa in general, approximately 59% of pregnancies are unintended. With legalized abortion, there can be open dialogue about different options for women. However, South Africa still has considerable distance to go. Maternal morbidity is high as approximately 50% of abortions are provided outside of clinic or hospital settings because of lack of information and stigma from the medical community and shame. Throughout sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere there is an on-going struggle of reaching out to women, particularly those from marginalized population groups because of fear, mistrust and high levels of stigma associated with termination of pregnancy.
The United States has reinstated the Mexico City Policy or “Global Gag Rule” which prevents access to US federal funds for any organization that offers or advises on family planning and reproductive health options if it includes information on abortion, even if these funds are not used for abortion-related services. The United States funds approximately $607.5 million for family planning assistance every year and the new restrictions would negatively impact a sum of $8.5 billion dollars, which goes to global health in general (over 50% of this for HIV/AIDS services). In many sub-Saharan African communities, uptake of contraceptive services is low as are interactions with the healthcare community, in part due to on-going stigma. Studies have shown that those organizations, which decide to forego the US funding will have fewer resources for family planning and contraceptive services in general including general HIV prevention.
Discussion and open communication is the key to bridging the gap between marginalized communities and access to healthcare including voluntary HIV testing and counseling, access to ARTs and other medications. There is still much work to be done to reduce the stigma and fear that communities face in their interactions with healthcare workers. The answer is not to shut off communications in one area. Pregnancy and unintended pregnancy are part of a woman’s reproductive health and by denying counseling and discussion in this and associated areas, we will push away women and communities who need our services.
South Africa and the future
South Africa represents some of the hope for the African continent as the laws here and the constitution protect the rights of women even if they are not universally enforced as domestic violence, rape and other acts against the rights of women are at high levels. However, even in South Africa, there are on-going challenges of providing quality reproductive, HIV and sexually transmitted infection (STI) health care to women due to stigma. Open communication and trust is the answer to bridge these divides and we need to go forward providing more comprehensive services and information, not less.
Janet M. Wojcicki is an Institute for Global Health Sciences Faculty Affiliate and associate professor in the UCSF School of Medicine, Department of Pediatrics. This article first appeared in Reproductive Health.
Towards Polio Eradication: What's Needed to Finish the Job
By Jaime Sepulveda, MD, MPH, MSc, DrSc
Farm Work and Flowcharts
By Michael Ladd, GHS master's student
Reflecting on Perceptions of Women in South India
By Joan C. Chang, GHS master's student
Traveling Beyond Stereotypes
By Pal Shah, GHS master's student
By Rhea Mathew, GHS master's student
Haile Debas Reflects on the Election of Dr. Tedros as WHO Director-General
By Haile Debas, MD
10,000 Miles Away, But Close to Home
By Carolyn Smith Hughes, GHS master's student
Reflecting on CUGH 2017
By Claire Kidiiga, RN, BSN, GHS master's student